Flood effects provide evidence of an alternate stable state from dam management on the Upper Missouri River

Katherine Skalak; Adam J. Benthem; Cliff R. Hupp; Edward R. Schenk; Joel M. Galloway; Rochelle A. Nustad

doi:10.1002/rra.3084

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70185565

Flood effects provide evidence of an alternate stable state from dam management on the Upper Missouri River

Katherine Skalak·Adam J. Benthem·Cliff R. Hupp·Edward R. Schenk·Joel M. Galloway·Rochelle A. Nustad

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

We examine how historic flooding in 2011 affected the geomorphic adjustments created by dam regulation along the approximately 120 km free flowing reach of the Upper Missouri River bounded upstream by the Garrison Dam (1953) and downstream by Lake Oahe Reservoir (1959) near the City of Bismarck, ND, USA. The largest flood since dam regulation occurred in 2011. Flood releases from the Garrison Dam began in May 2011 and lasted until October, peaking with a flow of more than 4200 m 3 s −1 . Channel cross-section data and aerial imagery before and after the flood were compared with historic rates of channel change to assess the relative impact of the flood on the river morphology. Results indicate that the 2011 flood maintained trends in island area with the loss of islands in the reach just below the dam and an increase in island area downstream. Channel capacity changes varied along the Garrison Segment as a result of the flood. The thalweg, which has been stable since the mid-1970s, did not migrate. And channel morphology, as defined by a newly developed shoaling metric, which quantifies the degree of channel braiding, indicates significant longitudinal variability in response to the flood. These results show that the 2011 flood exacerbates some geomorphic trends caused by the dam while reversing others. We conclude that the presence of dams has created an alternate geomorphic and related ecological stable state, which does not revert towards pre-dam conditions in response to the flood of record. This suggests that management of sediment transport dynamics as well as flow modification is necessary to restore the Garrison Segment of the Upper Missouri River towards pre-dam conditions and help create or maintain habitat for endangered species. Published 2016. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA.

Explore related subjects

River Research and Applications Article

Source-reported bounding extent: 44.25° to 48.5° latitude; -104.25° to -100° longitude. This indicates report coverage, not an exact sampling location. View area on OpenStreetMap.

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Katherine Skalak, Adam J. Benthem, Cliff R. Hupp, Edward R. Schenk, Joel M. Galloway, Rochelle A. Nustad. 2016-10-07. Flood effects provide evidence of an alternate stable state from dam management on the Upper Missouri River. https://doi.org/10.1002/rra.3084

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

How tough a passage? Nonnative fish entrainment survivability at a major dam in the western USA

The Colorado River downstream of Glen Canyon Dam (GCD) in the southwest USA demonstrates anthropogenic modification including altered flow and temperature regimes and established nonnative species in upstream reservoirs. Water overallocation and megadrought are contributing to new potential invasion pathways for nonnative fishes through dam releases. In this study, we quantified factors that influence survival of fish entrained at GCD, a pathway for nonnative fishes to leave Lake Powell and enter the Grand Canyon as reservoir levels remain near historic lows since the reservoir initially filled. We measured conditions of entrainment through GCD using a mechanical Sensor Fish device and evaluated potential barotrauma by comparing our results to previous studies. Under measured conditions, a fish's gas bladder would expand by a factor of 2.7 due to entrainment, potentially resulting in injury from barotrauma. We estimated members of Centrarchidae may survive entrainment at problematically high rates across all water levels where entrainment is expected. Minimizing nonnative fish entrainment through GCD is best achieved through maintenance of water levels higher than those in recent years, potentially decreasing both entrainment likelihood and survival.

Arizona↗

USGS2026

IVyTools: Space-Time Image Velocimetry for streamflow

Accurate streamflow measurements are essential for hydrologic monitoring, flood forecasting, and water resource management. Traditional in situ methods, although reliable, are often impractical or unsafe during flood conditions or at inaccessible locations. Image velocimetry techniques offer a potential non-contact alternative, yet operational adoption has been hindered by the lack of standardized, open-source tools, particularly for Space–Time Image Velocimetry (STIV). This paper introduces IVyTools, an open-source software application for operational streamflow measurement using STIV. Developed by the US Geological Survey (USGS), IVyTools integrates standardized streamflow measurement protocols into a reproducible, quality-controlled workflow that includes video preprocessing, orthorectification, velocity estimation, and streamflow (discharge) computation. The software incorporates a dual-method uncertainty framework based on ISO 748:2007 and an adapted Interpolated Variance Estimator (IVE), enabling users to quantify and diagnose measurement uncertainty. Validation against an independently published benchmark dataset demonstrates that IVyTools achieves a mean absolute percentage error of 4.56% (MAE = 5.16 m 3 /s ) from field-measured reference discharges, with acceptable performance across diverse river conditions. This work supports the broader adoption of image-based streamflow measurement methods and provides a foundation for potential future automation and integration into real-time hydrologic networks.

River Research and Applications↗

USGS2026

Non-physical barrier design and environmental conditions alter routing and survival of juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta

Pacific salmon face substantial challenges when migrating through anthropogenically modified river systems, such as the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta (the Delta). Non-physical behavioral barriers, such as the bioacoustic fish fence (BAFF), are one potential solution for guiding fish away from hazards without obstructing water flow. However, the effectiveness of these technologies depends on abiotic and biotic conditions. In the Delta, a BAFF was deployed at Georgiana Slough in 2011, 2012, and 2024 to deter juvenile Chinook salmon ( Oncorhynchus tshawytscha ) from migrating into the interior Delta, a region associated with lower survival than the mainstem Sacramento River. We leveraged nine years of acoustic telemetry data to evaluate BAFF performance across flow conditions and two BAFF designs (2011/2012 vs. 2024), and to assess the BAFF's contribution to improving through-Delta survival. The BAFF reduced routing into Georgiana Slough from 26.5% without a barrier to 8.9% in 2011/2012 and 15.9% in 2024. In general, routing into Georgiana Slough increased with the proportion of flow entering the channel during periods without a BAFF and during the 2024 deployment but remained constant during the 2011/2012 deployment. Additionally, BAFF effectiveness declined with increasing input flow. Ultimately, reduced routing into Georgiana Slough during the 2024 BAFF deployment resulted in an increase in estimated through-Delta survival between 0.2 and 1.6 percentage points depending on release group. Our results provide valuable insights into the role of non-physical barriers in complex river systems and inform future management strategies for protecting migrating juvenile Chinook salmon in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta.

California↗