Geology ReportsSearch

Geology topics

B. May

Publications and source records attributed to B. May.

8 recordsLinked to original sources

Genetic variation among interconnected populations of Catostomus occidentalis: Implications for distinguishing impacts of contaminants from biogeographical structuring

Exposure to contaminants can affect survivorship, recruitment, reproductive success, mutation rates and migration, and may play a significant role in the partitioning of genetic variation among exposed and nonexposed populations. However, the application of molecular population genetic data to evaluate such influences has been uncommon and often flawed. We tested whether patterns of genetic variation among native fish populations (Sacramento sucker, Catostomus occidentalis) in the Central Valley of California were consistent with long-term pesticide exposure history, or primarily with expectations based on biogeography. Field sampling was designed to rigorously test for both geographical and contamination influences. Fine-scale structure of these interconnected populations was detected with both amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) and microsatellite markers, and patterns of variation elucidated by the two marker systems were highly concordant. Analyses indicated that biogeographical hypotheses described the data set better than hypotheses relating to common historical pesticide exposure. Downstream populations had higher genetic diversity than upstream populations, regardless of exposure history, and genetic distances showed that populations from the same river system tended to cluster together. Relatedness among populations reflected primarily directions of gene flow, rather than convergence among contaminant-exposed populations. Watershed geography accounted for significant partitioning of genetic variation among populations, whereas contaminant exposure history did not. Genetic patterns indicating contaminant-induced selection, increased mutation rates or recent bottlenecks were weak or absent. We stress the importance of testing contaminant-induced genetic change hypotheses within a biogeographical context. Strategic application of molecular markers for analysis of fine-scale structure, and for evaluating contaminant impacts on gene pools, is discussed.

Molecular Ecology

Genetic comparison of lake sturgeon populations: Differentiation based on allelic frequencies at seven microsatellite loci

The lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) has recently become a high priority for restoration management because of the near extinction of the species from many areas of North America. The identification of the level of population differentiation that naturally exists among lake sturgeon populations will be useful in the development of management plans to conserve and restore diversity, and in the choice of donor populations to use for re-introduction. Genetic variation among and within 210 lake sturgeon collected from seven locations (St. Lawrence River, Des Prairies River (tributary to the St. Lawrence River), Mattagami River (Hudson Bay drainage), Menominee River (Lake Michigan drainage), Wolf River (Lake Michigan drainage), Niagara River, and Lake Erie) was examined based on allelic variation at seven microsatellite loci (four disomic and three putative tetrasomic). High levels of variability were detected at these loci. Analyses revealed an average of 8.6 alleles per locus (range 5 to 12 alleles per locus) and heterozygosity values at the four disomic loci ranging from 0.46 to 0.66. Multivariate factor analysis of Nei's genetic distance values produced three distinct population groups that were organized by geography: 1) Mattagami (northern Quebec), 2) Menominee/ Wolf (Lake Michigan - Wisconsin), and 3) St. Lawrence/ Des Prairies/ Niagara/ Erie (lower Great Lakes). Differences based on G-tests summed over all loci occurred between all possible paired comparisons of the collections (P < 0.01). These analyses indicated that lake sturgeon populations are differentiated within the Great Lakes basin. Managers of this species will need to identify individual populations in their jurisdictions and provide separate consideration for their conservation and rehabilitation.

Journal of Great Lakes Research

Genetic comparison of naturally spawned and artificially propagated Lake Ontario lake trout fry: Evaluation of a stocking strategy for species rehabilitation

Two strategies have been used in the effort to restore lake trout Salvelinus namaycush to Lake Ontario. First, lake trout strains from multiple wild and hatchery sources have been stocked to maximize genetic variability in the lake, Second, a unique hatchery “strain” of fish to be stocked was created each year with gametes collected from adult, hatchery‐origin fish that had survived to maturity after being stocked into Lake Ontario. Several hatchery strains may be represented among the adults captured and used to propagate this unique strain, termed the “Ontario strain.” The “Ontario strain” may have a genetically based potential for enhanced survival over other strains stocked in Lake Ontario because it is composed of the progeny of fish that have survived from the yearling to the adult life stage, Unlike naturally spawned fish, however, the “Ontario strain” has been shielded from natural selection during the critical period of mortality from spawning through the first year of life, The purpose of this study was to determine whether the “Ontario strain” was genetically representative of the wild fry produced in the lake, We examined the strain composition of three year‐classes of wild‐caught fry and six year‐classes of the “Ontario strain” using allozyme data with mixed‐stock analysis. The hatchery and wild fry were genetically dissimilar. In addition, the composition of the “Ontario strain” changed from predominantly Seneca strain in 1983–1984 to predominantly Superior and Killala strains from 1983 to 1989. Mixed‐stock estimates indicated that in contrast to the hatchery‐reared fry, strain composition of wildcaught fry did not vary greatly from year to year. Progeny of Seneca × Seneca crosses were the predominant fry in the three year‐classes of wild fry. The genetic dissimilarity between the “Ontario strain” fry and wild‐caught fry could be caused by differential mortality among the wild fry between spawning and fry emergence or by differential vulnerability of strains to the gill‐net sampling used to capture adults for gamete collection. Based on these results, the development of a new hatchery brood stock from wild‐caught fry is recommended as an alternative to the collection and propagation of gametes from mature hatchery‐origin lake trout. In addition, the composition of the hatchery strains stocked should be altered to emphasize those strains that reproduce successfully. Both options should be considered in order to speed the rehabilitation process.

Lake Ontario

Preservation of genetic variation in the Green Lake strain lake trout derived from remnant domestic and feral populations

The Green Lake, Wisconsin, strain of lake trout Salvelinus namaycush was discontinued as a hatchery brood stock in 1976 after Lake Michigan was stocked with the 1975 year‐class. In 1982, a decision was made to restore the Green Lake strain as a production brood stock. Five groups were produced by spawning marked fish that were survivors from the 1976 stocking of southern Lake Michigan. A sixth group was produced from a remnant of the Green Lake brood stock held at the Genoa (Wisconsin) National Fish Hatchery. Hatchery accidents reduced both the number of groups and the effective population number of each group. We studied a procedure for reconstructing a composite Green Lake brood stock from individuals of these six groups. Genetic variability was evaluated by allozyme electrophoresis in five of these groups. Twelve of 18 loci were polymorphic. Allelic frequencies were similar in all five groups; however, significant differences occurred in nine systems. Heterozygosity level (mean ± SE) was lowest in the domestic group (0.119 ± 0.043) and ranged from 0.139 ± 0.043 to 0.166 ± 0.052 in the feral groups. Cluster analysis of genetic distances grouped the four feral groups together, but separate from the domestic group. Progeny from fish captured on Black Can Reef, Lake Michigan, in 1986 and 1988 were the most similar. A modified diallel mating design was developed to produce a composite brood stock from remnant feral and domestic fish. Pooled families from 1991 and 1992 diallel matings will be reared to maturity, then reciprocal crosses of the two year‐classes will be made to form the new composite Green Lake brood stock.

Wisconsin

Genetic differentiation among lake trout strains stocked into Lake Ontario

The lake trout Salvelinus namaycush is the focus of an international effort by fishery management agencies to restore this once‐native species to Lake Ontario. Evaluation of reproductive success and comparisons among stocked lake trout strains require genetic markers. We used allozyme variation to make genetic comparisons among strains of lake trout stocked into Lake Ontario. Forty‐two proteins presumed to be encoded by 102 loci were resolved electrophoretically; 18 loci were polymorphic. Among 16 samples from five principal origins (Finger Lakes, Great Lakes basin, northern New York–Adirondack, Manitoba, and mixed origins–Lake Ontario), the average observed heterozygosity was 0.029, and the proportion of polymorphic loci was 0.125. Significant differences occurred among the 16 samples at all 18 possible locus comparisons. The average F st value was 0.14. Hierarchical analysis indicated that the variation among samples within an origin was greatest within the Great Lakes basin, which included the greatest number of samples and represented the largest geographic area. Most variation observed among samples, however, occurred among origins. The 1983 and 1984 hatchery year classes produced from the 1978 Seneca brood stock did not differ significantly. The 1981 Seneca brood stock more closely resembled the sample of wild lake trout from Seneca Lake than progeny from the 1978 brood stock. The closer affinity of the 1981 brood stock to wild Seneca lake trout may be due to the larger number of wild adults from Seneca Lake used to found these fish than was used to establish the 1978 brood stock. Siscowet (“fat”) and “lean” lake trout from Lake Superior were significantly different from each other; however, the level of variation between them was not greater than that among samples from other origins, and thus did not support recognition of siscowet lake trout as a distinct subspecies. The Jenny Lake strain possessed a genetic affinity to the siscowet sample from Lake Superior. Historical reports about the origin of this strain suggest that siscowet lake trout from northern Lake Michigan may have been used to found this strain. Therefore, the Jenny Lake strain may serve as a gene source for the establishment of the siscowet lake trout in Lake Ontario. The substantial differentiation among lake trout strains reported here supports the feasibility of using allozyme markers to identify the parental sources of naturally produced young.

Lake Ontario

Inheritance of duplicated fumarase and phosphoglucomutase loci in lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush)

Two polymorphic, duplicated loci (fumarase-1,2 and phosphoglucomutase-3,4), previously undescribed in salmonids, were examined in lake trout to determine their electrophoretic expression, mode of inheritance, and linkage associations. Both loci appear to be located on chromosomes which show residual tetrasomy. Neither locus pair shows joint segregation with other loci examined or with each other.

Heredity