Streamflow characterization and effects of Interstate 26 highway construction on water-quality and channel morphology conditions of the French Broad River in Buncombe and Henderson Counties, North Carolina, 2019–22

Abstract

The North Carolina Department of Transportation began a series of highway construction projects to upgrade Interstate 26 (I–26) in Buncombe and Henderson Counties, North Carolina, starting in early 2020. The North Carolina Department of Transportation and the U.S. Geological Survey partnered in 2019 to monitor and assess water-quality and geomorphic conditions throughout the French Broad River corridor in areas near Interstate 26 highway construction activities. This report summarizes findings from multi-year water-quality and channel morphology monitoring from 2019 through 2022 in the French Broad River corridor near ongoing highway construction activities. Dissolved oxygen, pH, specific conductance, turbidity, and water temperature were monitored at six gaging locations, three of which were near highway sections undergoing construction during the study period from June 1, 2019, through December 31, 2022. Water quality was compared across three monitoring locations before and during construction using Brunner-Dette-Munk statistical tests, a nonparametric form of analysis of variance used for unbalanced datasets. Most Brunner-Dette-Munk test results detected insignificant effects of highway construction on water-quality conditions when controlling for monitoring location, except for the test of daily maximum specific conductance values. However, the effects of highway construction could not be isolated from other external factors that may have affected specific conductance, including an extended period of low streamflow and possible road salt application after winter storms. Additional Brunner-Dette-Munk tests, controlling for flow magnitude (streamflow quantiles) or hydrograph position (“rising limb,” “falling limb,” or “base flow”), did not suggest that highway construction affected water-quality conditions in the study area. Geomorphic surveys of the streambed and streambanks were performed in a 1-kilometer reach from 2019 through 2022 to assess geomorphic changes during the reconstruction of a bridge spanning the French Broad River. Bathymetric surveys of the streambed and light detection and ranging (lidar) scans of the streambanks were collected from a canoe using motion-compensated, real-time positioning solutions. Initial geomorphic surveys were used as a baseline to which subsequent repeat surveys were compared using geomorphic change detection analysis. Detectable elevation changes were determined using statistically robust thresholds, ensuring only changes exceeding measurement uncertainty were considered for interpretive analyses. Change detection results identified that 16.4 percent of the reach experienced detectable geomorphic change during the study period, with inter-survey changes ranging from 3.5 to 12.4 percent of the total reach. Most detectable change is attributed to the installation and reconfiguration of temporary construction pads; other changes are attributed to enlargement of a scour hole and upstream deposition near the bridge. Although anthropogenic activities and changes in streamflow regime contributed to these observations, the approach used in this study provides confidence that reported values reflect real geomorphic changes and not noise.