Do three massive coral species from the same reef record the same SST signal? A test from the Dry Tortugas, Florida Keys

Abstract

Paleoclimatologists have reconstructed century-long records of sea surface temperature (SST) in the Pacific using the Sr/Ca of massive corals, whereas similar reconstructions in the Atlantic have not proceeded at the same pace. Past research in the Florida Keys has focused on Montastrea spp. , an abundant and fast-growing massive coral, thus a good candidate for climate reconstructions. However, coral records from the Florida Keys are complicated by freshwater flux, which varies the Sr/Ca in seawater, thus confounding the Sr/Ca to SST signal. In this research, we compared the monthly Sr/Ca variations in three massive corals species ( Montastraea faveolata, Diploria strigosa, and Siderastrea siderea ) from the same reef in the nearly pristine Dry Tortugas National Park (24.70N, 82.80W) at the southwestern extent of the Florida Keys. This location is ideal for a calibration study as hourly water temperature records are available and the remote reef is far from mainland freshwater influence. These corals experienced the same environmental conditions (water depth, clarity, Sr/Ca of seawater, etc.) but differ in the mean annual growth rates (0.86 &plusmn;0.10 (1&sigma;) cm/year M. faveolata ; 0.67 &plusmn;0.04 (1&sigma;) cm/year D. strigosa ; 0.44 &plusmn;0.04 (1&sigma;) cm/year S. siderea ). The mean Sr/Ca values are not the same but decrease with mean annual growth rates (9.201 &plusmn;0.091 (1&sigma;) mmol/mol M. faveolata ; 9.177 &plusmn;0.081 (1&sigma;) mmol/mol D. strigosa ; 8.964 &plusmn;0.12 (1&sigma;) mmol/mol S. siderea ), thus supporting the &ldquo;vital effect&rdquo; or biological differences during calcification between coral species. The amplitude of the seasonal cycle in Sr/Ca varies with the slower growing S. siderea having the largest mean amplitude and D. strigosa the smallest (0.340 mmol/mol S. siderea ; 0.284 mmol/mol M. faveolata ; 0.238 mmol/mol D. strigosa ). We confirmed our sampling methods by conducting several intracolony and intercolony coral Sr/Ca replication tests and found a high correlation in all tests (>0.95 S. siderea ; >0.90 D. strigosa ; >0.83 M. faveolata; p < 0.05). The weighted linear regression of monthly coral Sr/Ca to mean monthly SST revealed that S. siderea captured the seasonal and interannual variability in SST ( r = -0.97, -0.61 monthly and monthly anomalies, respectively, p < 0.05). The other corals have reduced correlation with monthly anomalies and do not capture the seasonal variability with the same fidelity as S. siderea . All three corals were sampled along the thecal wall following the same procedures; however, each coral species has a different skeletal structure, density, and micro-scale growth patterns. We hypothesize the thecal wall of S. siderea calcifies at a continuous rate along the time-growth axis whereas the wall of D. strigosa and M. faveolata reflects a more complex signal. Of the three species, the slow growing S. siderea provides a robust reconstruction of mean monthly SST for the Dry Tortugas thus suitable for longer centennial-scale reconstructions.