Geology topics

Curtis J. Roth

Publications and source records attributed to Curtis J. Roth.

6 recordsLinked to original sources

USGS2025

Why the whole is greater than the sum of its parts: A case for population-level management

Catch-and-release regulations in recreational fisheries have been implemented for decades with the intention of allowing fishing while reducing fishing mortality. In addition, voluntary catch-and-release behaviors are increasingly common. Social and scientific interest in fish handling practices in catch-and-release fisheries as they relate to stress, reflex impairment, reproductive success, and mortality has been expanding. The scientific literature is now replete with studies that examine these issues, and they have become a fixture in the public discourse on angling. Scientists and anglers are making fishing regulation proposals and suggestions for fish-handling practices. The proximal intent of these recommendations is to reduce excessive stress or mortality on a per capita basis with a belief that the reduction ultimately has a positive effect on the population. Whether the proximal intent achieves population goals depends on several factors, including effort, population dynamic rates, and stock-recruitment dynamics. This perspective reviews the state of the science relative to a hierarchical framework of fishery population dynamics, with a call for fishery scientists to consider their scope of inference and assumptions relative to conservation and population management.

Article↗

USGS2019

Population ecology and evaluation of suppression scenarios for an introduced Utah Chub population

Introduced Utah Chub Gila atraria were first sampled in Henrys Lake, Idaho, in 1993, and their presence in the system is a concern given possible interactions with sport fishes. Our objective was to describe the population dynamics of Utah Chub in Henrys Lake. A total of 362 Utah Chub was sampled via gill nets, with an average catch rate of 20.5 fish/net-night (SE = 6.0) during May 2016. Average TL was 210 mm (SE = 3), and average weight was 134 g (SE = 5). Pectoral fin rays were used to provide estimates of growth and age structure. Utah Chub varied in age from 2 to 12 years, and recruitment was stable (recruitment coefficient of determination = 0.96). Estimated total annual mortality was 40% (SE = 4%). Fecundity of Utah Chub in Henrys Lake increased with length and varied from 6,232 to 156,797 eggs/female. Age-structured population models were constructed using the demographics data, and estimated average population growth rate over a 10-year period was 1.17. This study provides a comprehensive description of Utah Chub population dynamics and insight on their management in systems where they are not native. This information is not only useful for guiding management actions but also serves to further our understanding of Utah Chub ecology.

Idaho↗

USGS2019

Effects of air exposure on survival of Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout angled from a stream with warm water temperatures

We evaluated the effects of air exposure on Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout Oncorhynchus clarkii bouvieri caught and released in a cold-water stream with elevated water temperatures (i.e., > 14°C) in southeastern Idaho. Anglers caught fish in a 2.3-km section of Fall Creek, Idaho, during August 2018. Sampled fish remained underwater while we measured and then tagged them with T-bar anchor tags. We exposed fish to air for 0, 30, or 60 s and then released them at the point of capture. We continuously monitored temperature during the study period. Water temperatures during the study varied from 10.0 to 19.7°C and averaged 14.9°C (SE = 0.08). In total, anglers caught 161 Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout over 10 d. Of those fish, we did not expose 54 to air; we exposed 54 to air for 30 s, and 53 for 60 s. We used electrofishing to recapture tagged fish and estimate relative survival. Relative survival was highest for fish exposed to air for 60 s (0.40 [SE = 0.25]) followed by 0 s (0.35 [SE = 0.25]) and 30 s (0.30 [SE = 0.27]), but differences were not statistically significant. Results from this study are consistent with other air-exposure studies suggesting that air exposure of 60 s or less is not likely a concern in Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout fisheries. Releasing fish as quickly as possible is always encouraged, but management regulations restricting air exposure seem unnecessary given the collective body of field-based research on air exposure. Nevertheless, similar studies on other systems and species are warranted.

Idaho↗

USGS2018

Effects of air exposure during simulated catch-and-release angling on survival and fitness of Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout

Concerns have been raised regarding the practice of exposing fish to air during catch-and-release (C&R) angling. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of air exposure on short- and long-term survival and progeny production of Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout Oncorhynchus clarkii bouvieri . Prespawn adults were sampled at a weir during upstream migration in 2016 and 2017, exposed to a simulated angling event of 102 s, and then exposed to air for a randomly selected duration of 0, 30, or 60 s. An additional control group was added during 2017 in which fish were not exposed to simulated angling or air. In total, 1,519 fish were sampled in 2016, and 744 fish were sampled in 2017. Additionally, age-0 fish (2016: n = 2,924; 2017: n = 1,492) were collected to evaluate the effects of air exposure on the production of progeny. No effect of angling itself or of angling and air exposure was observed on short-term (≤60 d posttreatment) or long-term (>1 year posttreatment) survival of adults, with one exception. During 2016, fish that had been air exposed for 60 s had a statistically higher short-term survival rate than fish that received no air exposure. Air exposure had no effect on the proportion of fish that successfully spawned. Regression analysis revealed that neither angling nor air exposure affected progeny production. Considering that much of the literature, as well as this study, reports little to no influence of air exposure on salmonid mortality or reproductive success, it seems highly unlikely that air exposure of less than 60 s during C&R angling would have negative population-level effects.

Idaho↗

USGS2018

Effects of summer air exposure on the survival of caught-and-released salmonids

Despite the success of catch‐and‐release regulations, exposing fish to air during release has emerged as a growing concern over the past two decades. We evaluated the effect of air exposure during midsummer on survival of Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout Oncorhynchus clarkii bouvieri , Bull Trout Salvelinus confluentus , and Rainbow Trout O. mykiss exposed to catch‐and‐release angling. Fish were sampled by angling on Palisades Creek (August 2016), Sawmill Creek, and the Main Fork of the Little Lost River, Idaho (July−August 2017). After capture, fish were kept underwater while they were measured and individually tagged. Anglers, in groups of two to four, caught study fish and gave them an air exposure treatment of 0, 30, or 60 s. Single‐pass backpack electrofishing was then used to recapture tagged fish and estimate relative survival. In total, 328 Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout were sampled (0 s: n = 110; 30 s: n = 110; 60 s: n = 108), 278 Bull Trout (0 s: n = 92; 30 s: n = 94; 60 s: n = 92), and 322 Rainbow Trout (0 s: n = 103; 30 s: n = 106; 60 s: n = 113). The majority of fish were caught using artificial flies (≥92%) and were hooked in the corner of the mouth, lower jaw, or upper jaw (≥78%) in all three species. No difference in survival was observed among air exposure treatments for all three species. Results from the present study along with those from prior field studies of air exposure times during angling suggest that mortality from exposing fish to air for ≤60 s is not likely a population‐level concern in catch‐and‐release fisheries for these species.

Idaho↗

USGS2018

Fight and air exposure times of caught and released salmonids from the South Fork Snake River

Catch-and-release regulations are among the most common types of fishing regulations. In recent years, concerns have arisen regarding the exposure of fish to air during catch-and-release angling. The purpose of our study was to quantify the length of time angled fish were exposed to air by anglers in a typical catch-and-release fishery and relate it to the lengths of time reported to produce negative effects. In total, 312 individual anglers were observed on the South Fork Snake River, Idaho, from May through August 2016. Fight time varied from 1.1 s to 230.0 s, and average fight time was 40.0 s (SD = 36.8). Total air exposure times varied from 0.0 s to 91.8 s and averaged 19.3 s (SD = 15.0). Though not statistically significant, a trend in reduced fight times was observed when anglers were guided and increased air exposure times when a net was used and a picture was taken. Results of the current study suggest that anglers expose fish to air for periods that are much less than those reported to cause mortality.

Idaho↗